top of page
Search

The Toxic Side of Spiritual Forgiveness: When Forgiveness Becomes a Barrier to Trauma Recovery

Nov 7
6 min read
By Carrie-Leigh Bartlett, Pure Lotus Wellness
By Carrie-Leigh Bartlett, Pure Lotus Wellness

Does healing require forgiveness, and can spiritual pressure to forgive cause more harm than good?


What if I told you that you do not have to forgive someone to heal from what they did to you?


For many people, particularly those navigating spiritual healing, this statement may feel uncomfortable. Perhaps even controversial.


After all, forgiveness has become one of the most celebrated concepts within spirituality, religion, personal development, and even certain approaches to emotional healing.


We are told that forgiveness is freedom. That holding onto anger lowers our vibration. That resentment creates illness. That we must forgive those who have hurt us to move forward.


But what happens when these teachings are presented to someone who has experienced profound trauma?


What happens when a survivor of childhood abuse is told they must forgive their abuser to find peace?


Or when someone who has experienced betrayal, abandonment, emotional manipulation, or violence is encouraged to release their anger before they have even had the opportunity to process it?


This is where spiritual forgiveness can cross a dangerous line.


When forgiveness becomes an expectation rather than a personal choice, it can become another form of emotional invalidation.


The Spiritualization of Forgiveness


Within many spiritual communities, forgiveness is portrayed as an essential step toward enlightenment, energetic alignment, or spiritual evolution.


We hear statements such as:


- "Forgiveness raises your vibration."

- "You chose this experience for your soul's growth."

- "Holding onto anger means you're giving away your power."

- "Everything happens for a reason."

- "You must forgive to release the energetic connection."


While some individuals may find comfort or meaning in these beliefs, they can be deeply damaging when imposed upon trauma survivors.


This is sometimes referred to as spiritual bypassing; using spiritual beliefs or practices to avoid, minimize, or prematurely move past difficult emotional and psychological experiences.


Instead of allowing someone to experience their grief, rage, fear, or betrayal, spiritual bypassing encourages them to transcend those feelings.


But trauma cannot simply be transcended through positive thinking, affirmations, or forced forgiveness.


And someone who is still angry about what happened to them is not spiritually unevolved.


They may simply be responding to something that should never have happened.


When Forgiveness Becomes Another Violation of Autonomy


One of the most significant consequences of trauma, particularly childhood trauma, is the loss of personal autonomy.


For many survivors, their boundaries were ignored, their voices silenced, and their ability to make choices taken away.


Their feelings may have been dismissed. Their experiences denied. Their reality questioned.


Now imagine that same individual entering a spiritual or healing environment and being told that forgiveness is necessary for their recovery.


Once again, someone else is telling them what they must feel, what they must release, and how they must heal.


The very process intended to help them reclaim their power can unintentionally recreate the dynamics of their original trauma.


Trauma-informed healing should restore choice, not remove it.


A survivor deserves the right to decide whether forgiveness has any place in their healing journey.


And that decision should never determine whether they are considered healed, evolved, compassionate, or spiritually connected.


Anger Is Not the Enemy


One of the most harmful messages within certain spiritual teachings is that anger represents a lower vibrational state that must be eliminated.


But anger is a natural human emotion.


For trauma survivors, anger can carry important information.


  • It may be the first time they recognize that what happened to them was wrong.


  • It may signal the awakening of boundaries that were never permitted to exist.


  • It may represent the emergence of a voice that was silenced for decades.


For someone who spent their childhood surviving through compliance, people-pleasing, or emotional suppression, experiencing anger can be a significant part of reclaiming their identity.


Anger does not automatically mean someone is consumed by hatred.


It does not mean they are refusing to heal.


And it certainly does not mean they are spiritually deficient.


Anger can be acknowledged, understood, and expressed safely without being directed toward revenge or harm.


Sometimes anger is the part of us that finally recognizes we deserved better.


The goal of trauma recovery is not to eliminate every uncomfortable emotion.


It is to develop the capacity to experience emotions safely, understand their meaning, and respond to them without becoming overwhelmed.



The Nervous System Cannot Be Shamed Into Forgiveness


Trauma is not simply a collection of painful memories.


Traumatic experiences can affect the nervous system, emotional regulation, beliefs about safety, and the way individuals respond to perceived threats.


Someone may intellectually understand that an experience is over while their body continues to respond with fear, hypervigilance, tension, or protective behaviours.


  • This is not a failure to forgive.


  • It is not evidence of spiritual weakness.


  • And it is not something that can necessarily be resolved by deciding to let go.


When forgiveness is introduced as a requirement, survivors may begin suppressing emotions they believe are preventing their healing.


  • hey may feel guilty for continuing to experience anger.


  • They may judge themselves for still feeling hurt.


  • They may attempt to reconnect with people who have harmed them before they feel emotionally or physically safe.


In some cases, this pressure can intensify shame, confusion, and self-blame.


Healing requires opportunities to develop safety, emotional awareness, boundaries, and meaningful choice.


Forgiveness cannot substitute for nervous system regulation, trauma processing, or rebuilding a sense of safety.


Forgiveness Is Not the Same as Acceptance


One of the greatest misunderstandings surrounding trauma recovery is the belief that accepting what happened means forgiving the person responsible.


These are two very different experiences.


Acceptance can mean acknowledging that something happened, recognizing its impact, and understanding that the past cannot be changed.


  • It does not mean approving of what happened.


  • It does not mean excusing the behaviour.


  • And it does not mean releasing the person responsible from accountability.


A survivor can accept their history without forgiving the person who caused the harm.


  • They can move forward without reconciliation.


  • They can establish peace without restoring a relationship.


  • They can build a meaningful, fulfilling life while maintaining the belief that what happened was unacceptable.


You can release the responsibility of carrying someone else's actions without releasing them from responsibility for those actions.


The Harm of Premature Forgiveness


In trauma recovery, timing matters.


When someone is encouraged to forgive before they have processed their experiences, they may feel pressured to bypass important stages of emotional healing.


For survivors who learned early in life to prioritize other people's feelings, forgiveness can sometimes become another form of people-pleasing.


  • They may forgive because they feel obligated.


  • Because they fear being perceived as bitter.


  • Because their spiritual teacher encourages it.


  • Because their family wants everyone to move on.


  • Or because they believe their healing depends upon it.


But forgiveness that comes from pressure, fear, guilt, or obligation is not necessarily a reflection of emotional freedom.


Sometimes it is simply another survival response.


This is particularly important when working with survivors of childhood trauma, who may have spent years being taught to minimize their own suffering to preserve family relationships.


Asking these individuals to forgive prematurely can reinforce the very patterns they are working to change.


Can Forgiveness Ever Be Healing?


Absolutely.


For some people, forgiveness becomes a deeply meaningful part of their recovery.


It may help them release resentment, redefine their relationship with the past, or find a sense of emotional freedom.


For others, forgiveness may never feel necessary or appropriate.


Both experiences deserve respect.


Forgiveness can be beneficial when it emerges from personal choice rather than external pressure.


It should never require reconciliation, renewed contact, denial of harm, or the abandonment of healthy boundaries.


And it should never be used as a measurement of someone's progress.


There is no universal emotional milestone that every trauma survivor must reach.


Healing is not a competition to see who can forgive the fastest.



A Different Spiritual Perspective: Healing Without Forced Forgiveness


What if spirituality stopped asking survivors to forgive and instead began asking:


  • Do you feel safe?


  • Have your experiences been acknowledged?


  • Are you allowed to feel angry?


  • Do you have the freedom to establish boundaries?


  • Are you learning to trust yourself again?


  • Can you honour your own needs without guilt?


Perhaps spiritual growth is not about transcending our humanity.


Perhaps it is about learning to embrace it.


Our grief, anger, sadness, and fear are not evidence that we are disconnected from our spiritual selves.


They are part of the human experience.


True compassion should include compassion for ourselves.


And unconditional love should never mean unconditional access to us.


  • We can recognize the humanity of someone who harmed us without minimizing their actions.


  • We can wish someone well from a distance.


  • We can choose never to speak to them again.


  • We can acknowledge the lessons we have learned without expressing gratitude for the trauma that taught them.


And we can find inner peace without ever saying, "I forgive you."


Reclaiming the Right to Heal on Your Own Terms


At Pure Lotus Wellness Retreat, my approach to trauma recovery is rooted in safety, autonomy, connection, healing, growth, and integration.


I believe that healing should never require someone to abandon their truth to meet another person's spiritual expectations.


The journey is not about becoming the person others believe you should be.


It is about reconnecting with the person you were never given the freedom to become.


  • Sometimes that involves forgiveness.


  • Sometimes it involves anger.


  • Sometimes it involves grief, boundaries, distance, or the decision to walk away.


And sometimes it involves finally saying:


"What happened to me was wrong. I deserved better. And I do not have to forgive anyone to reclaim my life."


Forgiveness is a choice. Healing is a journey.


And the two are not dependent upon one another.


You do not owe anyone forgiveness in exchange for your freedom.


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page