When Spiritual Seeking Becomes Spiritual Taking
Updated: Nov 12

Cultural Appropriation, Ancestral Roots, and Finding a Spirituality That Is Actually Ours
There has been an enormous spiritual shift happening in the Western world.
People are questioning the religions they inherited.
They are questioning institutions, patriarchy, religious trauma, colonialism, dogma, and the idea that there is only one acceptable path to the Divine.
For many people, especially those of European ancestry, Christianity has become complicated.
We cannot talk about the history of Christianity in North America without acknowledging that Christian institutions were sometimes deeply intertwined with colonialism and forced assimilation.
Indigenous spiritual traditions were suppressed. Ceremonies were prohibited. Children were separated from their families and cultures through residential and boarding-school systems.
Conversion was frequently presented not simply as a spiritual choice, but as part of becoming "civilized."
Those histories deserve to be acknowledged. And understandably, some people today want nothing to do with what they perceive as the religion of the colonizer.
They begin looking elsewhere:
They discover Buddhism.
Hindu traditions.
Indigenous spirituality.
African spiritual traditions.
Shamanic practices.
Eastern philosophies.
Sacred medicines.
Energy practices.
Ancient symbols.
Ceremonies from cultures completely different from their own.
And somewhere along the way, something strange can happen.
In trying desperately not to resemble the colonizer, we can accidentally reproduce the behaviour of colonization itself.
We begin taking.
A ceremony from here.
A sacred word from there.
A deity from another tradition.
A piece of clothing.
A ritual.
A sacred medicine.
A title.
A symbol.
An initiation.
A practice we learned during a weekend retreat.
Soon we have constructed a spiritual identity out of pieces of other people's cultures.
And because our intentions are loving, spiritual, peaceful, or healing, we assume there cannot possibly be anything problematic about it.
But good intentions don't automatically answer the deeper question: Was this ours to take?
Spirituality Does Not Automatically Make Something Respectful
This can be an uncomfortable conversation in spiritual communities. Nobody wants to think of themselves as culturally insensitive. Especially people who genuinely care about healing, equality, Indigenous rights, social justice, trauma recovery, or spiritual freedom.
Yet spirituality doesn't magically remove us from cultural power dynamics. Sometimes it actually gives appropriation prettier language.
Instead of saying: "I took something from another culture because I liked it,"
We might say:
"Spirit called me to it."
"I remembered this from a past life."
"The medicine chose me."
"I have always felt connected to this culture."
"My guides told me I was meant to teach this."
Those statements may hold profound personal meaning for someone. But personal spiritual conviction does not automatically give us cultural authority.
Feeling connected to a tradition and belonging to a tradition are not necessarily the same thing.
And believing we have received spiritual permission is not necessarily the same as receiving permission from the human beings whose culture created and protected that practice.
That distinction matters.
Appreciation and Appropriation Are Not the Same Thing
This conversation also needs nuance. Cultural exchange is part of human history.
People migrate.
People marry across cultures.
Religions spread.
Teachers teach students from different backgrounds.
Communities invite outsiders to participate.
Traditions influence one another.
So the answer cannot simply be:
"You may only practice spirituality belonging to your genetic ancestry."
That creates an entirely different set of problems.
Many spiritual and religious traditions openly welcome people from outside the culture in which they originated.
There is a tremendous difference between respectfully studying Buddhism with Buddhist teachers and simply taking Buddhist imagery because it looks peaceful in your meditation room.
There is a difference between being welcomed into a ceremony and recreating it yourself after attending one.
There is a difference between learning a spiritual practice through an established teaching lineage and taking fragments of a tradition from social media and declaring yourself qualified to teach it.
There is also a difference between participating and claiming authority. That may be one of the most useful distinctions we can make.
You can deeply love something without needing to own it.
You can learn.
You can listen.
You can participate when invited.
You can financially support teachers and communities.
You can acknowledge where teachings came from.
You can allow another tradition to profoundly influence your life without positioning yourself as its representative.
Respect doesn't require separation. Sometimes it simply requires humility.
The Spiritual Buffet

Modern Western spirituality has created something I sometimes think of as a spiritual buffet.
Take a little Buddhism.
Add a Hindu deity.
Mix in some Indigenous terminology.
Add Celtic symbolism.
Throw in chakras.
Add angels.
Include sacred geometry.
Perhaps some Kabbalah.
Add something described as "shamanic."
Put crystals around it.
Call the whole thing ancient wisdom. But ancient to whom? From where? Practiced by whom? Under what circumstances?
This is where spiritual practices can become detached from the people who created them.
A ritual becomes an aesthetic.
A sacred object becomes décor.
A religious symbol becomes jewellery.
A ceremony becomes a workshop.
A cultural title becomes a marketing term.
A medicine becomes a wellness trend.
And eventually the original culture can almost disappear from the practice entirely.
When Sacred Traditions Become Products
This becomes particularly uncomfortable when money enters the picture.
Imagine a community whose ancestors were punished for practicing their spirituality.
Their ceremonies were suppressed.
Their language was discouraged or prohibited.
Their sacred objects were taken.
Their children were taught that their ancestral beliefs were primitive, sinful, or uncivilized.
Then, generations later, someone from outside that community discovers part of that spiritual tradition.
They package it beautifully.
They market it.
They teach it.
And they make money from it.
Suddenly something one group was historically punished for practicing becomes fashionable when someone else sells it as wellness.
That should at least make us stop and think.
The question isn't necessarily: "Am I forbidden from touching this?"
A much healthier question might be: "What is my relationship to this practice, and am I treating it with integrity?"
The Irony of Escaping the Colonizer
There is another layer to this conversation that I believe deserves much more attention.
Many white spiritual seekers are actively trying to separate themselves from Christianity because they associate Christianity with colonization. And there are legitimate historical reasons for wrestling with that history.
But sometimes the rejection becomes: "Christianity is the colonizer's spirituality. I want something older, more Indigenous, more natural, more feminine, more mystical."
So we go searching through other cultures.
And we take what resonates.
But think about the irony.
Colonialism frequently operated from an assumption that European people had the right to enter another culture and decide what had value.
Today we may reject the theology behind colonization while unconsciously retaining another habit: the belief that everything in the world is available for us to take if we find it meaningful.
Different motivation.
Similar entitlement.
Instead of taking land or resources, we may take spiritual practices. Instead of saying, "This belongs to us now," we say, "This resonates with me."
That doesn't make every cross-cultural spiritual practice appropriation.
But it does mean that "it resonates with me" cannot be the end of our ethical examination.
I Have to Include Myself in This Conversation

If I’m going to talk honestly about cultural appropriation within modern spirituality, then I also have to be willing to turn the mirror toward myself.
I am a middle-aged white woman working in the spiritual and wellness world.
And yes, I have studied and practised modalities whose origins are not part of my own ancestral culture.
Reiki is Japanese. The westernized version is much different than that taught in Japan. Morphed into a modality that is a melting pot of many energy beliefs.
I have studied aspects of Ayurveda, a healing tradition with deep roots in India.
Over the years, like many people within the Western spiritual community, I have been introduced to teachings, practices and philosophies that originated in cultures very different from my own.
And the more I have learned about cultural appropriation, colonization and the commercialization of spirituality, the more I have had moments of discomfort.
I think that discomfort is important. Because my response cannot simply be, “But my intentions are good.” Good intentions do not automatically equal respectful practice.
Instead, I have tried to become much more conscious about where the things I practise actually came from.
I sought out teachers of the original way Reiki was taught. Now, when I teach Reiki, I believe it matters that I acknowledge its Japanese origins and the history behind the practice rather than presenting Reiki as some generic form of “ancient energy healing” detached from the people and culture through which it developed. I never did before.
When I learned about Ayurveda, I want to understand that I am encountering a vast Indian knowledge tradition. Not simply borrowing a few ideas about doshas, herbs or wellness because they happen to fit nicely into Western spirituality.
There is a difference between learning from another culture and pretending that culture belongs to you.
There is also a difference between being invited into a teaching, studying it respectfully and acknowledging its lineage, versus stripping pieces from a tradition, renaming them, commercializing them and presenting them as your own spiritual discovery.
And I am still learning where those lines are.
I don't think the answer is necessarily that we must never learn anything outside of our ancestry. Human beings have exchanged knowledge, philosophy, medicine and spiritual ideas across cultures for thousands of years.
But I do believe we have a responsibility to ask better questions.
Who taught me this?
Where did this practice originate?
What did it mean within the culture it came from?
Was this traditionally an open practice, or was it sacred, restricted or initiatory? Reiki was.
Am I acknowledging the lineage when I teach it?
Am I changing something I don't fully understand?
Am I profiting from a tradition while knowing almost nothing about the people who preserved it?
And perhaps one of the most uncomfortable questions: Why am I searching everywhere else for spirituality while knowing so little about the spiritual traditions of my own ancestors?
That question has become particularly important for me.
Rather than trying to distance myself from being a white woman by collecting spiritual identities from other cultures, I can also turn toward my own ancestry and ask what existed there before Christianity became dominant.
For me, that has meant exploring my Scottish ancestry and learning more about Celtic history, folk traditions, Pagan practices, folklore and the complicated history of what we now loosely call witchcraft.
That doesn't mean I abandon Reiki or reject everything I have learned from traditions outside my ancestry. It means I try to hold those teachings with respect rather than ownership.
I can say, “This teaching came from somewhere. People carried it before me. I am a student of it.” And I can simultaneously continue digging into the traditions that belong to my own ancestral story.
Maybe cultural awareness in spirituality isn't about creating perfectly sealed boxes where nobody is ever allowed to learn from anyone else.
Maybe part of it is learning the difference between appreciation, participation, education and entitlement.
It requires humility.
It requires research.
It requires acknowledging lineage.
And sometimes it requires admitting: I didn't always think about this.
I know more now. And because I know more, I want to practise differently.
So Where Did Our Own Spirituality Go?
This is where I believe the conversation becomes really interesting for people of European ancestry.
Because perhaps before asking, "Whose spirituality can I borrow?"
We could ask: "What happened to the spirituality of my own ancestors?"
Christianity wasn't always the religion of Europe.
Long before Christianization, Europe contained an enormous diversity of spiritual traditions.
Celtic traditions.
Germanic traditions.
Norse traditions.
Baltic traditions.
Slavic traditions.
Greek and Roman religions.
Regional folk practices.
Ancestor traditions.
Seasonal observances.
Sacred landscapes.
Local spirits.
Herbal knowledge.
Divination.
Folklore.
Healing customs.
Household rituals.
And countless practices that never fit neatly into the modern category of "religion."
Many disappeared. Some were absorbed into Christianity. Some survived through folklore and folk customs. Others have been reconstructed through archaeology, historical texts and surviving cultural traditions.
And perhaps there is something incredibly healing about turning around and looking backward. Not because DNA determines what we are spiritually permitted to believe. But because understanding our ancestors gives us context.
Researching My Own Roots

This has become particularly meaningful to me.
My own ancestral research has brought me back toward Scotland and toward exploring the Celtic and pre-Christian traditions associated with the places my ancestors came from.
That naturally raises questions for me about Scottish folk belief, Celtic spirituality, seasonal traditions, folklore, magic, healing practices and the history of witchcraft in Scotland.
And I find something beautiful about that.
Instead of needing to become somebody else spiritually, I can ask:
Who were my people?
What did they believe before Christianity?
What survived after Christianization?
What stories did they tell?
What did the land mean to them?
What plants did they use?
What seasons mattered?
What folklore survived?
What did Scottish people historically mean when they talked about witches, cunning folk, healers, fairies, second sight or magic?
What is historically documented, and what has been added by modern Paganism?
Those distinctions matter to me. Because reclaiming ancestral spirituality shouldn't mean inventing an ancestry we wish we had.
It means researching the one we actually have.
For me, that means exploring my Scottish roots and my connection with Celtic Paganism and Scottish folk-magic and witchcraft traditions while still being willing to ask what is historical, what is folklore, what is reconstruction, and what belongs to modern spiritual practice.
There is tremendous freedom in saying: "I am learning."
I don't have to claim that every practice I feel drawn toward was practiced exactly as I practice it today.
I don't need an unbroken line of witches stretching back a thousand years to make my spiritual life meaningful.
I can honour what we know. I can acknowledge what we don't.
And I can consciously create something meaningful in the present without rewriting the past to justify it.
Ancestry Is an Invitation to Research, Not a Certificate of Authority
There is an important caution here too. Taking an ancestry test and discovering that you have Scottish ancestry doesn't automatically make you a Celtic priestess.
Discovering Scandinavian ancestry doesn't instantly make you an authority on Norse religion.
Finding Indigenous ancestry somewhere in a family tree doesn't automatically grant membership, cultural belonging or ceremonial authority within an Indigenous nation.
Ancestry can give us a doorway into research. It can create curiosity. It can help us understand where our families came from.
But culture is more than DNA.
Culture involves community, history, language, relationship, lived experience and, in some traditions, specific initiation or recognition.
Ancestral exploration should therefore create more humility, not more entitlement.
Spirituality Shouldn't Become a Costume
Perhaps this is ultimately what bothers me most about cultural appropriation in spiritual spaces.
Spirituality is supposed to bring us closer to ourselves. Yet sometimes we use it to become somebody else.
We adopt another language.
Another culture's clothing.
Another culture's ceremonies.
Another culture's sacred objects.
Another culture's titles.
And gradually spirituality becomes another identity we perform.
But perhaps the deeper spiritual question isn't: "What can I add to myself?"
Perhaps it is: "What remains when I stop trying to become someone?"
There is something profoundly spiritual about knowing where we stand.
Knowing our history.
Knowing our ancestry.
Knowing what we inherited.
Knowing what harmed our ancestors and what sustained them.
Knowing which patterns deserve to end with us and which traditions deserve to be remembered.
And then approaching everyone else's traditions with curiosity rather than entitlement.
Before Adopting a Spiritual Practice, Ask Yourself...
Before incorporating something from another culture into your spiritual life, perhaps sit with these questions:
Where did this practice actually originate?
Not where TikTok says it originated. Not where a retreat leader says it originated.
Where does the historical evidence lead?
Is this an open tradition or a practice with cultural, ceremonial or initiatory boundaries?
Who am I learning it from?
Are they connected to the tradition they're teaching?
Who taught them?
Am I participating, or am I claiming authority?
There is an enormous difference.
Am I giving credit to the people and culture this came from?
Am I making money from something another community considers sacred?
If so, that deserves serious reflection.
Have people from that culture expressed concerns about outsiders using this practice?
If they have, have I actually listened?
Am I changing the practice and still presenting my version as authentic?
Am I romanticizing this culture?
Do I know anything about these people beyond the spiritual practices I find attractive?
Would I still value this tradition if I couldn't teach it, sell it, post photographs of it or make it part of my spiritual identity?
That one might be especially revealing.
And finally:
Have I spent as much time investigating my own ancestral history as I have investigating everybody else's?
Maybe Spirituality Is About Coming Home
I don't believe spirituality needs more gatekeeping. I don't believe human beings should live in isolated cultural boxes where nobody learns from anybody else. And I certainly don't believe our DNA should dictate our spiritual beliefs.
Humanity has always shared ideas.
We have always travelled, migrated, married, traded, taught and learned from one another.
That exchange can be beautiful. But exchange requires relationship. Respect requires listening. And spiritual curiosity requires humility.
Perhaps the goal isn't to build walls around spiritual traditions.
Perhaps it's to learn how to enter another person's sacred space without assuming everything inside belongs to us.
To be invited without taking ownership.
To learn without declaring ourselves masters.
To appreciate without consuming.
And sometimes, instead of constantly travelling outward searching for another culture to tell us who we are, perhaps spirituality asks us to travel backward.
Into our family stories.
Into genealogy.
Into history.
Into folklore.
Into the landscapes our ancestors inhabited.
Into the traditions that disappeared, survived, changed or became hidden inside other customs.
For me, that exploration leads toward Scotland, Celtic spirituality, Pagan traditions, folklore, folk magic and the complicated history surrounding witchcraft.
For someone else, the trail may lead somewhere completely different. And you may discover things you love. You may discover things you don't.
Ancestral healing isn't about pretending our ancestors were perfect. It is about being willing to know them.
Because perhaps the most respectful way to encounter the sacred traditions of the world is not to ask: "Which one can I make mine?"
But instead: "What can I learn from you while allowing you to remain yours?"
And then to turn toward our own history and ask: "What was mine that I never knew existed?"
There is a difference between collecting spirituality and developing a spiritual relationship.
One asks us to gather more. The other asks us to go deeper.
And perhaps the path toward a more respectful spiritual world begins when we stop trying to wear someone else's sacred identity, and become curious about our own.





Comments